Is EMST overused? An SLP and RMT expert breaks down the research on EMT and IMT for dysphagia, cough, voice, device selection, and dosing.
Is expiratory muscle strength training (EMST) overused by SLPs? That question came up in an SLP Facebook group recently, and my answer got long enough that it needed its own home. So here it is.
For those who don't know me: I'm Brooke Richardson, MS, CCC-SLP. I'm still clinical in acute care, and I teach respiratory muscle training (RMT) to SLPs, PTs, OTs, and RTs through Breathehab. This is a huge area of interest for me.
For what it's worth, I don't work for or represent any device company. Everything here is my opinion, based on my clinical work, the research, and my experience teaching clinicians all over the world.
I started my RMT journey at a prior hospital and I'm grateful for that foundation. Once I had the basics down, I had a lot more questions about RMT and devices. I've spent thousands of hours since then learning this stuff inside and out.
A quick note on terms: "EMST" is sometimes incorrectly used to refer to a specific device, often Aspire's EMST150 or EMST75 Lite. EMST and EMT (expiratory muscle training, the term used in much of the world) both mean the therapy, not a brand. IMT is inspiratory muscle training, and RMT covers both.
I'm writing for SLPs here, but none of these questions or challenges are unique to SLPs. I'm not picking on us!
The short version
- Is EMST overused? Yes and no. Some clinicians use EMT and IMT without understanding them well enough, but concern about overuse isn't unique to EMT.
- The research: there's evidence that EMT and IMT can help swallowing, cough, and communication, AND evidence that they may not be as effective as previously thought.
- What makes or breaks RMT: candidacy, strength testing, device selection, and dosing.
- Don't forget the inspiratory muscles! IMT is underused.
Short answer: yes and no. And any concern about overuse or misuse isn't unique to EMT.
On the whole, I believe SLPs are doing the best we can with the research and tools available.
Do some SLPs use EMT and IMT without understanding them well enough? Yes, absolutely (that's why I teach courses on RMT).
Can incomplete knowledge lead some clinicians to overuse one or both? Yep.
Thoughtful treatment planning in speech pathology is crucial, whether it involves RMT or not.
Device companies have devices to sell, right? No shame there at all. But marketing and sweeping claims can drive device sales very effectively, and it's our professional duty to understand all the ins and outs of a therapy and its devices.
It's very human to buy into a technique because there's a device attached. Devices increase patient buy-in because there's something tangible (a rarity in SLP!), and as professionals we're not immune to this risk. A device can subconsciously make an intervention feel more professionally legitimate, which can potentially soften how critically we look at it.
The onus is on each of us to make sure the therapy we're doing, device-driven or otherwise, is right for that patient. Every time. When a device is involved, perhaps we need to be extra aware of our biases and buy-in.
Many SLPs share a trait of altruism. With that comes a drive to "do something" for our patients, or a belief that "something is better than nothing." Sometimes that's true. But especially with ever-growing scrutiny of billing and skilled services, our therapy plans need to be conscientious.
I've seen many a compassionate SLP start RMT simply because a patient has trouble breathing. In some cases of dyspnea, RMT may be indicated. But if breathing difficulty comes from widespread tissue damage alone, it may not be.
And we always need to target a functional impairment within our scope. Difficulty breathing on its own isn't something SLPs treat.
There's less research on EMT than IMT overall, since IMT has been around longer and been studied more broadly. I'm excited to see that changing, including in critically ill patients. I hope our research colleagues keep studying both across populations and SLP-specific disorders.
Research will never be 100% in favor of... pretty much anything in medicine. On the whole, though, I believe there's sufficient evidence to support thoughtful use of EMT and IMT as part of our care plans. Here are a couple examples of how that plays out.
Short answer: the research on EMT for dysphagia and dystussia/hypotussia (weak cough) isn't as strong as our field generally perceives, but individual studies show promise. And whatever the strength of that evidence, skill training for cough can't be ignored.
This is the area where I'd argue, more than other SLP uses, that EMT may be overused. But that's not unique to EMT either. We face a lot of pressure to "do something" or pick people up for treatment. My heart especially bleeds for SLPs who are refused access to instrumental swallow assessments, which are crucial for choosing the right dysphagia treatment, EMT or otherwise.
Every day I see SLPs discussing EMT for swallowing and cough. Several small, well-designed studies show improvements in swallowing and/or cough function after an EMT program. But the research is heterogeneous (not unlike our caseloads):
Partly because of that heteorgeneity, reviews don't currently agree on whether EMT has measurable effects on swallowing outcomes in people with dysphagia. For example, a 2020 systematic review of EMST and videofluoroscopic outcomes couldn't complete a meta-analysis because study methods varied so much.
Meta-analyses and systematic reviews are helpful tools, but they don't mean we ignore the studies inside them. EMT can improve swallowing function. As with any intervention, it simply won't work for everyone.
Research increasingly suggests that skill training for cough may be more beneficial than strength training. In a 2023 randomized controlled trial of 65 people with Parkinson's disease and dysphagia, both EMST and sensorimotor training for airway protection (smTAP) improved expiratory strength and voluntary cough. Only the skill-based smTAP group also improved reflex cough outcomes.
If cough is an area you want to learn more about, Drs. James Borders, James Curtis, and Michelle Troche are a few researchers to follow.
Brief soapbox: don't forget the importance of inspiratory muscle strength in cough function.
Short answer: EMT and IMT can benefit voice and speech, and they aren't guaranteed to affect laryngeal tension either way. Dose is important. Always incorporate functional voice and speech tasks in therapy.
The balanced activity of the inspiratory and expiratory muscles provides the steady subglottic pressure phonation needs. So when caring for people with dysarthria or dysphonia, think about both muscle groups.
Expiratory recoil is only truly passive during quiet rest breathing. It isn't exclusively passive during active tasks like phonation or exercise, or during expiration in people with lung disease like COPD.
Improving muscle strength could also reduce the effort needed for expiratory drive during phonation. Think of the different tensions on a rubber band between your fingers, right before you release it and fling it at my face for the length of this post.
With this in mind, strengthening the expiratory muscles follows a good line of logic.
Several studies show EMT improves expiratory force in people with voice disorders, and other papers highlight benefits of IMT.
The Academy of Neurologic Communication Disorders and Sciences (ANCDS) dysarthria guidelines suggest that some people with dysarthria may benefit from directly targeting the respiratory subsystem-- by targeting the respiratory subsystem in some way, the result may be producing more syllables per breath and speaking for longer periods of time.
Theoretically, could increasing force through a device increase tension in the larynx? Sure. One small study in healthy adults (Sandnes et al., 2013) used laryngoscopy during inspiratory training on a resistive device. Fewer participants showed vocal fold abduction when the load was at or above 80% of maximal inspiratory pressure (MIP) than at 60 to 80%.
Again, device selection and dosing are important, and that can't be overstated.
The only way to really know whether tension is changing for an individual is instrumentation like laryngoscopy. Even then, I'd want to see what happens under different loads (device settings), during quiet breathing, and during voice and speech tasks.
The underlying idea: if we improve phonatory drive by improving respiratory muscle strength, while also incorporating functional tasks in our therapy, we may see less excess tension and phonatory effort in people with strain and/or spasticity.
Much of that depends on the etiology and severity of the impairment, and on the person's ability to do the RMT tasks.
Would RMT be my initial go-to for a pure ataxic dysarthria? Not necessarily. Might I incorporate it if there's respiratory weakness affecting communication? Certainly would consider it. It boils down to the etiology of the impairment, whether respiratory muscle weakness is present, and which subsystems the disease or injury affects.
Brief soapbox: SLPs should also consider the importance of inspiratory muscle strength in phonation.
Short answer: most SLPs would benefit from boning up on this.
Some devices have a more robust research base, including studies by authors not affiliated with the device or company. Some companies have only internal research, or extremely limited outside research, and that carries a huge inherent risk of bias. I've also seen companies cite RMT research as if it were done on their device when it wasn't even on the same type of device (*cries in ethics*).
Cost varies a lot too, from about $55 for a single-patient device to $500+ for a multi-patient device.
We can't be married to a device because it's the one we know, the one in the closet at work, the one advertised everywhere, or the one SLPs are always talking about. I recommend SLPs choose a device that:
Sometimes we're lucky and that's the device we have at work. Other times, we might need to advocate for change.
Current evidence in rehabilitation supports pressure-threshold devices over resistive devices. There's also good evidence for electronic tapering devices, which are multi-patient use (with filters) and cost hundreds of dollars apiece.
The landmark EMT studies, and most since, used the EMST150, a pressure-threshold device. Dr. Christine Sapienza is one of the creators of that device and an author of many papers including its use.
RMT device companies list many contraindications and precautions that are grossly theoretical. Fortunately (knock on wood), I haven't yet come across a study where harm was done.
I'm not a black-and-white kind of SLP, and I don't toss those lists aside either. I use them as guidelines, and whenever possible I include physicians (like surgeons) and patients in shared decision-making if I think there could be harm.
To choose a device and know what to set it to, we have to understand the research and the person's medical comorbidities. We also must complete a thorough evaluation of their strength.
When possible, I recommend always testing both inspiratory and expiratory muscle strength (MIP and MEP), regardless of which modality you expect to use.
Dosing is so important. Too-high or too-low of a device setting isn't effective. Many EMST protocols set the load at 75% of maximum expiratory pressure (MEP). A 2026 study in people with poststroke dysphagia also found greater submental muscle activation on sEMG at 75% of MEP than at 25% or 50%. Older studies have found similar.
In people with ALS, myasthenia gravis, and critical illness, for example, we have to be careful not to overtax their systems. We often need to start at a lower load that's still effective enough, and make sure they tolerate exercise before we consider increasing it. I don't start these individuals at the default 70-75% of their max.
So, we'll rely on their diagnosis(es), functional impairment(s), and strength testing to determine a load and choose a device.
I'd argue we're underusing inspiratory muscle training as SLPs. IMT has incredible benefits across the continuum of care, and more studies are looking at it in rehab beyond cardiopulmonary populations, including Parkinson's disease.
Both inspiratory and expiratory muscle training also have general health benefits: blood pressure, pelvic floor, balance, and exercise tolerance, to name a few. Healthy people can benefit from RMT, too.
Can we always do RMT and bill for it as a skilled service? Not if there's no SLP-specific impairment we're treating. When there is an impairment in our scope, we may see spread effects of RMT to other areas in that person. We also need to be prepared to refer to other non-SLP specialists for RMT if we think the person could benefit from someone beyond our scope.
Expiratory muscle strength training (EMST, or EMT) is a form of respiratory muscle training. The person breathes out forcefully into a device with a one-way, spring-loaded valve that opens only at a set pressure. SLPs use it for swallowing, cough, voice, and speech impairments when respiratory muscle weakness is part of the picture.
Research supports EMST for improving expiratory strength, and individual studies show swallowing and cough improvements in some populations. Systematic reviews don't agree on its effects on swallowing outcomes, so use it thoughtfully, with careful candidacy decisions and instrumental assessment whenever possible.
EMST trains the muscles used to breathe out and submental muscles. IMST (inspiratory muscle training) trains the muscles used to breathe in, including the diaphragm and some upper airway muscles. Some patients need one, some need both, and some need neither.
Many EMST protocols use 75% of maximum expiratory pressure (MEP), and loads that are too low may not be effective. Some people, such as those with ALS, myasthenia gravis, or critical illness, may need to start lower. Measure MIP and MEP before choosing a device or a load. ALWAYS individualize to the patient rather than relying solely on strict protocols.
It's possible in theory, and load needs to be considered. One small study of inspiratory training in healthy adults found fewer people showed vocal fold abduction at loads of 80% of MIP or higher. Laryngoscopy at different loads is the only way to know what's happening for an individual.
RMT needs to target a functional impairment within SLP scope, such as dysphagia, dysphonia, or dysarthria. Difficulty breathing alone isn't an SLP-treatable impairment. Check your payer's specific requirements and your state/national scope of practice.
If this post raised more questions than it answered, good! That's exactly why I built Breathehab: device-agnostic, evidence-based RMT education for SLPs, PTs, OTs, and RTs.
Brooke Richardson, MS, CCC-SLP, is a medical speech-language pathologist with clinical experience in adult acute care and ICU settings since 2009. She founded Breathehab to provide device-agnostic, evidence-based respiratory muscle training education across disciplines, and The Modern MedSLP for medical SLP continuing education. She speaks and mentors internationally.
Categories: : EMT, Healthcare